When selecting benches for urban spaces, the cost comparison between wood and metal involves more than just the initial purchase price. You need to consider long-term value, maintenance requirements, and durability to make a truly informed decision.
Initially, wooden benches often appear more budget-friendly. Basic pressure-treated pine models can start as low as $200-$400 per unit. However, premium hardwoods like teak or mahogany can escalate to $800-$1,500+ due to their natural resistance to elements. Metal benches, particularly cast iron or heavy steel designs, typically command higher upfront costs ranging from $500 to over $2,000 for ornate, durable pieces. Aluminum options provide a lighter, more affordable metal alternative.
The true cost difference emerges in long-term maintenance. Wood requires regular sealing, staining, or painting every 1-2 years to prevent rotting, warping, and insect damage. These ongoing maintenance expenses add significantly to the total lifecycle cost. Metal benches, especially aluminum or powder-coated steel, need minimal upkeep—typically just occasional cleaning and touch-ups to address scratches that could lead to rust.
Durability reveals another cost dimension. Properly maintained hardwood benches can last 10-20 years, while softwoods may need replacement in 5-10 years. Metal benches often survive 25+ years with minimal care, making them more cost-effective over decades despite higher initial investment.
Consider your specific environment: wooden benches can splinter in high-traffic areas, while metal becomes uncomfortably hot or cold in extreme climates. The most economical choice depends on your budget, maintenance capabilities, and performance expectations. Many urban planners find that investing in quality metal benches provides better long-term value, while wood offers immediate aesthetic appeal at a lower entry point.