Short answer: yes, they can—and some materials are much worse than others. I’ve sat on a dark metal bench in July that felt hot through jeans, so I get the concern.
Metal benches are the biggest culprits. Dark iron, steel, or aluminum in direct sun can reach 140–170°F (60–75°C) on the surface. That’s hot enough to cause a burn in seconds if you’re wearing shorts or put your hand down without thinking. Lighter metal still gets hot, but dark colors are the worst.
Wood is usually more forgiving. It conducts heat slowly, so a wooden bench may feel very warm or even hot after hours of sun, but it rarely burns as aggressively as metal. Dark-stained hardwoods can still get uncomfortable.
Plastic and composite benches are hit or miss. Cheap plastic can warp, soften, or become slick with heat. Dense recycled plastic can get surprisingly hot. Composite materials with lighter pigments or wood fibers tend to stay a little cooler, but direct sun still heats them up.
Color and shade make a huge difference. A black bench in full sun can be 20–40°F hotter than a pale bench nearby. Shade from a tree, building, or awning can drop the surface temperature by 30°F or more. If you’re choosing a place to rest, look for light colors and shade first.
For summer bench safety, do a quick hand test before sitting. Hold your palm or the back of your hand an inch above the seat. If it feels like a stovetop, it’s too hot. Use a towel, jacket, newspaper, or bag as a barrier if you have to sit. Mornings and evenings are safer, while midday from about 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. is when surfaces peak.
Bottom line: yes, street benches can get too hot to sit on in summer, but it depends on the material, color, and sun exposure. A quick touch test and a little shade go a long way.