When selecting benches for public spaces, the choice between traditional hardwood and modern recycled plastic is crucial. Both have distinct advantages.
Hardwood, like oak or teak, offers classic beauty and natural strength. It's sturdy and has a timeless appeal that blends with many landscapes. However, it requires regular maintenance like sealing or staining to prevent weathering, splintering, and rot. Its lifespan can be long with proper care, but it is susceptible to graffiti and insect damage.
Recycled plastic benches are made from post-consumer plastics like milk jugs. Their primary benefits are exceptional durability and minimal upkeep. They resist moisture, insects, graffiti, and splintering, needing only occasional cleaning. They are a sustainable choice, diverting waste from landfills. The downside can be a less natural appearance and potential for fading or warping in extreme heat, though modern composites have improved.
Key differences lie in maintenance and lifecycle. Hardwood demands ongoing care, while plastic is largely maintenance-free. Environmentally, hardwood is renewable but involves forestry, whereas recycled plastic repurposes waste but is not biodegradable. Cost-wise, recycled plastic often has a higher initial price but lower long-term costs due to minimal upkeep.
The best choice depends on your priorities. Choose hardwood for classic aesthetics and natural feel in well-maintained areas. Opt for recycled plastic for maximum durability, low maintenance, and strong sustainability credentials in high-traffic or vandal-prone locations. Many urban planners now use a mix, placing plastic benches in demanding spots and hardwood in more curated parks.