That's an excellent question, and one we hear often from customers weighing their options. From a durability and maintenance standpoint, recycled plastic benches consistently outperform traditional wooden ones in the long run. Here’s a direct, honest comparison based on real-world performance.
The core advantage of recycled plastic is its resistance to the very elements that break down wood. Unlike wood, it won't rot, splinter, or succumb to insect damage. You'll never need to sand, stain, or seal it. A simple wash with soap and water is all it takes to look new again. While wood has a classic aesthetic, it requires annual maintenance to prevent graying, cracking, and structural weakness. A plastic bench might have a higher initial cost, but it eliminates recurring maintenance expenses and labor.
In terms of holding up, plastic benches are incredibly resilient. They are designed to withstand extreme sun (UV stabilized), heavy rain, and freezing temperatures without warping or cracking. A high-quality wooden bench can last too, but only with diligent care. Without it, deterioration is inevitable.
The feel is different, of course. Wood is naturally warm and traditional. Modern recycled plastic benches, however, are engineered with textured finishes that mimic wood grain and are surprisingly comfortable. They are also substantially heavier, making them more resistant to theft or tipping.
So, if your priority is a truly low-maintenance, durable, and eco-conscious solution that looks good for decades with zero upkeep, recycled plastic is the superior performer. If you cherish the ritual of maintenance and the authentic, evolving patina of natural wood, that remains a valid choice. For most public spaces, commercial properties, and homeowners seeking hassle-free longevity, recycled plastic holds up far better.