That's an excellent and very practical question. When you picture a park bench, the classic wooden slat design often comes to mind. But for a high-traffic downtown area, your concern about durability is absolutely valid. Let's break it down honestly.
The short answer is: it depends heavily on the wood and upkeep. Not all wooden benches are created equal. A bench made from untreated pine won't last a season. However, benches crafted from dense, rot-resistant hardwoods like teak, ipe, or thermally modified ash are a different story. These woods naturally withstand moisture, insects, and heavy use far better. They are a viable option, but with significant caveats.
For a busy downtown, the challenges are real. You have constant use, exposure to sun and rain, potential for vandalism, and spilled food or drinks. Even the best wood will eventually show wear, requiring a strict maintenance schedule of cleaning, inspection, and re-sealing or re-oiling every year or two to prevent cracking and graying.
So, are they a *good* choice? They can be, if you prioritize aesthetics and are committed to long-term maintenance. Wood offers a warm, natural, and classic look that complements many urban landscapes. But if your primary goal is maximum durability with minimal upkeep, you might consider alternatives. Powder-coated aluminum or recycled plastic lumber benches often offer superior weather resistance, require almost no maintenance, and can handle relentless use in a busy core.
Ultimately, the decision balances aesthetics, budget, and maintenance resources. For a truly busy downtown, investing in premium hardwood with a dedicated care plan is the only way to make wood a lasting choice. Otherwise, modern, low-maintenance materials might be the more durable and cost-effective solution for your urban space.