That's an excellent question, and one we hear often. The short answer is: modern metal benches can be just as comfortable as wooden ones, but they achieve comfort in different ways. Let's break it down.
Wooden benches offer a classic, naturally warm feel. The material has a slight give, which some people find instantly welcoming. However, comfort heavily depends on the design. A simple flat plank can become uncomfortable quickly, while a contoured seat with proper back support makes a world of difference. The main comfort challenge with wood is maintenance; without regular sealing, it can splinter, warp, or retain moisture, leading to an uneven surface.
Today's high-quality metal benches are designed with comfort as a priority. Through ergonomic shaping—like curved seats and supportive backrests—they provide excellent lumbar support. Many feature wide, slatted designs that distribute weight evenly. The key advantage is consistency; powder-coated aluminum or steel won't warp or splinter, so the comfortable shape you bought is the shape you keep for years. The common concern about temperature is mitigated with thick slats or coatings that insulate against heat and cold better than thin metal.
So, which is more comfortable? For initial, traditional "softness," a well-crafted wooden bench is lovely. For long-term, consistent support with minimal upkeep, a thoughtfully designed metal bench is often the superior choice. Ultimately, the most comfortable bench is one with a thoughtful ergonomic shape, regardless of material. We recommend trying both to feel the support for yourself!